Insights

What do your decisions say about your values?

< Back to Insights

How everyday experiences shape employees’ beliefs about organisational values

Editorial illustration showing a high-performing employee being rewarded while colleagues look uncomfortable, highlighting the tension between organisational values and workplace decisions.

Imagine working for an organisation that prides itself on respect being one of its core values. It features prominently in recruitment materials, new employees learn about it during induction, and managers attend workshops exploring what respectful behaviour looks like in practice.

Now imagine that one of its highest-performing employees regularly treats colleagues poorly. Their behaviour is well known, but they continue to deliver excellent results and are regarded as someone the organisation can’t afford to lose. Eventually, they’re promoted, with their achievements publicly recognised and celebrated.

What might their colleagues conclude from that decision? The organisation has spent considerable time explaining that respect matters, yet the promotion appears to communicate something different.

What the research tells us

Recent research from Nottingham Trent University examined the relationship between organisational commitments and employees’ everyday experiences. Surveying 1,178 UK employees, researchers found that 53% perceived some or strong inconsistency between their employer’s wellbeing policies and what happened in practice, while around 44% reported inconsistencies involving diversity, equity and inclusion policies.

These are employees’ perceptions rather than independently verified policy failures, but they matter because they influence how people understand the organisation they work for.

The researchers also found that employees’ perceptions of leadership behaviour and hiring and promotion practices were strongly associated with how closely they believed organisational culture reflected its stated values.

This connects with research on behavioural integrity, which looks at how consistently people believe leaders’ actions match what they say. Research has found strong associations between perceived behavioural integrity and employee trust and commitment, alongside positive relationships with performance.

The message is worth considering. Employees don’t judge organisational values solely by what they’re told. They also draw conclusions from the decisions and behaviours they experience.

When values meet competing priorities

One way organisations make values meaningful is by translating them into observable behaviours. Few people would disagree with a value such as respect, but what respect actually looks like in practice can mean different things to different people. Observable behaviours create clear, shared expectations and provide a basis for recognising and addressing behaviour that falls short.

For example, treating people respectfully might mean listening to different opinions, speaking to colleagues courteously, challenging inappropriate behaviour and treating people with dignity.

But defining those behaviours doesn’t necessarily mean they’ll be reinforced in practice. An organisation might encourage collaboration while rewarding individual achievement, or emphasise accountability while being reluctant to challenge influential people.

That doesn’t automatically mean the organisation lacks commitment to its values. Leaders face genuine competing demands, and financial or operational constraints sometimes prevent them from achieving everything they would like. What matters is whether those values continue to influence decisions when circumstances become difficult.

There’s also the question of interpretation. Research by Lisa Nishii and colleagues found that employees attributed different motives to organisational HR practices, with those interpretations associated with differences in commitment and satisfaction. Leaders may understand why a decision was necessary without appreciating what employees have concluded from it.

Looking beyond what we intend

Perhaps we need to spend less time checking whether employees understand organisational values and more time examining whether those values influence everyday decisions.

One useful starting point is to examine a recent decision where employees might reasonably have expected an organisational value to influence the outcome. What influenced the decision? How was the value considered? What did the people affected experience, and what conclusions might they reasonably have drawn?

The answers might reveal a need for clearer communication, but they could also expose organisational practices that reinforce behaviour contrary to the expectations everyone has agreed.

Think back to the promotion decision in our opening example. The organisation wanted to recognise outstanding performance, but what might colleagues have learned about respect?

Perhaps the most revealing question about our organisational values isn’t whether employees know what they are. It’s what they would conclude matters most from the decisions and behaviours they experience every day.

Hi, I'm Simon, the founder of Growth Consulting and I'd love to hear your insights on this post and other issues affecting you and your teams.
Get In Touch

Recent Posts

© 2026 Growth Consulting Solutions. All Rights Reserved.
Site by Artsphere Creative

Start a Conversation

I'd love to chat more about how I can help you get the best out of your teams and leaders. Pop me a message below to start a conversation about how I can help do that.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)
Newsletter